SMALL BIZ ADVICE
What would you ask Michael?
The Dell Community has contributed: 9800 ideas | promoted 668513 times | 76318 comments

How IdeaStorm Works:

Post Promote Discuss See

alokjain

Dashboard  |  Ideas Submitted  |  Ideas Voted On  |  Comments  |  Saved Items

1080

The Real Advantages of Linux

Linux submitted by cosh 03/30/07 **COMING SOON**

  • Linux is free. It's free for use on an unlimited number of computers. For ever.
  • There are a variety of excellent distros of it now. Similar goals, but different approaches, so you pick exactly what you want.
  • An amazing library of free, open programs are available for download with any and all distrobutions. Linux lets you explore these by category and choose which ones to try.
  • Linux is efficient and runs on pc's that have a significantly lower spec (and are therefore cheaper) than what Vista ever could.
  • Linux is proven secure. No viruses for Linux have ever propagated successfully, and there were only ever 14 of them.
  • Linux is absolutely top-of-the-range Open Source Software. Thousands and thousands and thousands of people have reviewed Linux's code, making constant improvements across the OS. Now, the end user can rely on it. Linux is amazingly stable.
  • Linux never stopped caring about where you wanted to go today. The designers always listen to problems, and then fix them.
  • OpenOffice is a flexible and powerful office-suite and is free for all to use. Again, this is high-quality Open Source Software.
  • Linux will let you play your music and movies without fuss.
  • Linux will let you browse the internet and email safely.
  • As well as being free in price, Linux is freedom. It never places DRM restrictions on you or spys on the way you use music and media. It just does what you ask.
  • Thanks to continuing work on the Windows compatibility layers WINE and CrossOver, you can run increasingly complex Windows programs directly in Linux if you prefer, including Office, Internet Explorer, Photoshop and iTunes. Explore some screenshots here.
  • Linux has huge online dedicated support communities. Dell can use those, to reduce the efforts of providing its own Linux support desks.


And for comparison, the disadvantages of Windows
  • Windows is frustratingly expensive plus you have to pay for it again if you have another computer. Windows license management is glued onto the operating system. It scans your hardware and uses the hardware key (sent to Microsoft's website of course) to track one copy of Windows across different computers.
  • If you don't like something that's changed in the new version, tough.
  • Windows makes even the basic computers in the Dell range more expensive because it's a memory and resource hog. Vista's requirements have forced basic memory used to manage the OS up four-fold. So with far more memory - you get the same results.
  • There are over 114,000 known viruses for Windows. See this list of viruses, and note how many do and don't begin with "W32" (which means Windows).
  • Windows is closed-source. Thousands of defects are permanently left in it because there simply aren't enough people working on it to iron them all out (or probably even notice them).
  • Windows is bossy and obtrusive. Vista is swamped with irritating security dialogs. You opened this file. Cancel or allow? You want to view this website. Cancel or allow? etc. People don't want to run operating systems - they want run applications and get on with what they're doing.
  • Windows Media Player (reportedly) submits reports of DVDs you watch to a file on Microsoft's server, tracked with an individual id. See this page. Surely to god nobody wants this? Or this?!?!
  • Look at this Microsoft diagram of how Vista plays HD video. Notice the repeated decryption and reencryption before the data gets sent to your screen. Notice the multiple "protected environments", and the fact that your prgrams are deemed to be "unprotected". Who is Vista trying to protect the video from? - YOU. This blatantly outrageous content protection is because it thinks you will try to share the video with friends and it doesn't want you to. Plus the multiple decryption stages of each frame of video put a frightening strain on the computer meaning only high-end computers will be able to play HD content in Vista (for the near future).
  • It's just... not nice. Not just the OS, but Microsoft's attitude. See the Halloween Documents if you haven't already. Microsoft's reports make a shocking read. Their attitude is cold and ruthless, and we don't like that, and we don't like Dell to be tied so tightly into that.


Linux is not the be-all and the end-all, but it is growing faster, much faster, than Windows. The Linux community can scale ten times the number of developers that Windows can. Arguably, it's set to soon be superior to Windows in virtually every respect.

Dual-booting options with Windows and Linux give maximum choice to the user. This option is a must for Dell computers. Microsoft's vendor-lock-in contracts which force PC retailers to support and "recommend" only Windows are unethical and we don't like them. It's gone on for too long. Let's be honest Dell, ask yourself, what are Microsoft so afraid of? Will they lose money through dual booting both Windows and Linux? No not if Windows was the better OS... So is Microsoft quietly admitting to it... Come on Dell, we all want you to show the world how much more a computer can be! We want you to show the world what a computer is meant to be, and marvel at people's suprise and delight! Giving your customers choice can only be a good thing. Don't ignore this chance to become the open source pioneer.

Might I suggest that promotion is vital. Linux computers will not sell well if they are hidden in some back-alley part of your website. To get the best results for the work you put in, make sure people can see it and that it is well-described, so people who've never heard of it don't get confused.

Make sure that you make these computers available to markets outside America too. Don't ignore us here in Europe! The European Commission's had quite enough of Windows anyway, after fining Microsoft €497 million ($603 million USD) for anti-competitive behavior.

Another idea, to iron out compatibility problems and get interesting extra feedback, beta-test some of your new Linux range with a large-ish selection of people before making it fully available. Unlike with Windows, you have full options to customise the style, background and layout and almost complete behavior of the OS. You might want to put your own touches on it. For example the default installation of Ubuntu is a light-brown/orange colour, which lacks much universal appeal. Test to see whether people want something layed out similarly to Windows or just barebones Linux defaults for the particular distro(s). (I personally would like something similar to Windows' look.)


Open the window. Linux is ready for Dell, and Dell is ready for Linux.

We appreciate the promises you've made already Dell. Thank you. We're all behind you and look forward to the results.



52 Comments »

400

Linux - Distribute Live Disks!!

Linux submitted by cosh 04/01/07

Earlier, I was trying to join the general support for Dell to do more computers with Linux pre-installed. But, reading the US Deparment of Justice Findings of Fact in the old Microsoft anti-trust case, I realised what a shockingly tight grip Microsoft have on OEM retailers. It's a long, confusing and scary read, but the important notion is this:

The more computers Dell (or any other OEM retailer) sell with Linux or without an OS, or the more they advertise Linux on their site, and the more they INCLUDE ANY OPEN-SOURCE SOFTWARE ON THEIR MACHINES WHICH COULD AT ANY LEVEL COMPETE WITH SOFTWARE FROM MICROSOFT, the higher price Microsoft can charge Dell for all versions of Windows that they want to sell. Thus, the cost of Windows PC's might go up for Dell.

How about, Dell do something different here. Just give away the live disks for a few different distros free with their computers. That way, you don't get into trouble with Microsoft at all. If Microsoft try to change the price they sell Windows at to Dell for just for bundling a simple free complimentary gift with their computers, it would be so blatantly illegal and anti-competitive and just what the Department of Justice is looking for - they would be on them in minutes. Maybe I'm being naîve but really I don't see how Microsoft could possibly retaliate...

<u>Advantages of using Live Disks:</u>

- It lets people still try Linux even if they wouldn't go for the dual-boot option. This method will give so much publicity to Linux - like nothing else ever could.

- It makes an amazing tool for support. If Windows goes wrong, the support personnel can ask if the user has their Linux disks available and use one of those to boot up and fix the problem. It also lets you test if a problem is with the hardware or with Windows or an application.

- You don't have to install it. Just put in the DVD (or CD) and restart the computer. Instant and workable Linux with no-risk. It doesn't attempt to write to the hard drive and cannot damage anything. Run OpenOffice, Mozilla Firefox, etc., straight from the DVD.

- You can include a few different distros on different disks, instead of just one.

- There's no danger from not knowing how to use Linux, because Windows is still the main OS. You just have some free bonus software with your PC is all.

- If you hate Linux, break the disks as some kind of ritual of it. Or whatever. It's your choice.

- It's extremely quick and easy for Dell to start with, because not everything has to work right with regards to driver issues. The disks are extremely good at auto-detecting hardware on the fly, but if, for example, there's no sound support running off the live disk, it doesn't matter, because it's not the main OS. Including a couple of live disks is quick and cheap and they tend to be packed with software, so it lets everyone get a hellova lot more for their money when they buy a Dell.

- It can also hugely boost popularity for having Linux installed on future computers. Dell can use this as an advert for dedicated Linux machines. And then lots more major retailers, like Dell, will see the opportunity. This could be the start of a real change and new flexibility in the market.



Want to know more about the inflatable penguin above? They were giving out demo disks of Linux. Read the short story here and see the photos here. The funniest bit from it is this:

Our presence also attracted one of the Ice House employees. He crossed the street, fully clad in Windows Vista sweater and hat, and approached me. "Hey, are you guys promoting Linux?" he asked. I nodded, smiling. "Can I get a CD? I'm curious, I'd like to try it," he continued. Trying not to laugh at the irony of it all, I gladly handed him a CD. He thanked me, and quickly ran back to the Ice House before anyone saw him with the Linux people.


Translation: Lots of people would like to try Linux, even if they wouldn't have it as a main operating system.

Open the window. Linux is ready for the world, and the world is ready for Linux. 9 Comments »

-70

Dell should read poetry

Service and Support submitted by cosh 04/14/07

"Is there anybody there?" said the Traveller,
After posting an idea;
And his screen in the silence, echoed neglect,
For no action would appear:

A forgotten promise from the moderator,
Was little to be read
And he stormed his idea a second time;
'Is there anybody there?' he said.

But no one ascended to the website;
No head from distant support
Leaned over and took up the keyboard,
To update the action report.

But still a cohort of heroes
That remained in the derelict then
Stood resolute in their conviction
For action- how much? and when?

Stood listening to the cries of despair,
For customer support and software,
With freedom from vendor lock-in,
And licenses unfair.

The Traveller felt in his heart the indifference,
Of Dell to the World's request,
For Linux, lit keyboards, and webcams
That would set Dell out from the rest.

For he suddenly smote on the keyboard, even
Louder, and turned on caps:-
'TELL THEM I CAME, AND NO ONE ANSWERED,
THAT I KEPT MY WORD', he said.

Never the least stir made the moderators,
Though every idea he wrote,
Went to the heart of the people,
As they rushed to demote or promote:

Ay, Dell saw the excite on the website,
And made token talk of work still to come,
But other retailers watched closer,
And soon had everything done.


The original is here. Some lines of it I didn't modify at all. Turned out Walter De La Mare had amazing forsight to predict in 1912 what would be happening on Dell Ideastorm 95 years later. If you read the comments there's lots more that people have added too.

33 Comments »

-50

Dell Spirit!

Sales Strategies submitted by captainsensible 02/28/07

In the old days Dell used to give out a birth certificate with every Dell system, like having a geek cabbage patch doll or something. Dell should include something like this, along with a tshirt, coffee cup, bumper sticker, keychain, and anything else that users could show off their new system with! We need spirit! 10 Comments »

-150

Top Ten/Demoting Stories/Clear the Clutter

IdeaStorm submitted by captainsensible 03/26/07

After about 8 hours of demoting linux repeats, suggesting changes to Windows (where's Microsoft's IdeaStorm), all kinds of 3rd party hardware Dell should sell, people posting their personal information, and blank posts galore, there should really be a Top Ten for the day/week/month/year.

Heey, throw in Top Demoted Posters too, for fun!

23 Comments »

-50

Bagtop: The Laptop-in-a-Bag!

Accessories (Keyboards, etc.), Laptops submitted by captainsensible 03/29/07

I move around with my laptop, so I'm forever repeating the
following cycle :

power off
unplug power
unplug mouse
unzip bag
stow laptop in bag
wind up power cable
stow power cable in bag
stow mouse in bag
zip up bag

...and the reverse to set up the laptop again.

How about the BagTop: your laptop *is* the bag. A cunningly designed bag that holds your laptop, presents all connected cables eg power/VGA (wound around self-tightening wheels) in a zip-up pocket, and directs the hot-air vents to a handy and safe exit point. With padding, slightly-beat-up-finish, handle and retractable shoulder straps like a rucksack.

You put your bag on the desk, open the lid (side-mounted zip)
and there's your computer. Unzip the port pouch, pull the plug
out and plug into the wall socket. Done. 7 Comments »

1441

Add Mac OSX

Operating Systems - Multiboot submitted by rmartin 02/17/07

Need to add Mac OSX. Esp good idea when bundled with Parallels software so you could run Windows and linux at the same time. v10.5 will be out soon that makes it an ever better idea. 136 Comments »

2467

Off sound switch before startup in laptops

Operating Systems, Laptops submitted by socunasindria 02/19/07

Many times in silent places i've got to plug headphones in my laptop just to avoid the startup windows sound.

It should be a switch button to avoid this. 14 Comments »

8095

Stop overcharging for upgrades (memory, hdd, etc. )

Accessories (Keyboards, etc.), Sales Strategies, Laptops submitted by uklathemock 02/17/07

Almost everyone I know buys the smallest harddrive and the lowest amount of memory for their Dell notebook, and then upgrades later. Why make your customers turn to other sources to buy memory and hard drives? I think quite a few e-tailers were created and have flourished because everyone (Dell, HP, Apple, etc.) overcharges for upgrades. 17 Comments »

120794

No Extra Software Option

Software submitted by ootleman 02/16/07 **PARTIALLY IMPLEMENTED**

Would love the ability to have a clean Vista install. No AOL software, no earthlink software, no google software - just a clean, original OS.


Check out jeremy_f's update on our current software options.


591 Comments »

21852

Laptop Web Cam and Microphone

Accessories (Keyboards, etc.), Laptops submitted by terrymain 02/16/07 **PARTIALLY IMPLEMENTED**

All new laptops should have a built in web cam and quality voice recorder/microphone.


Webcams are standard on all XPS laptops and an option on all Inspiron laptops.




134 Comments »

140599

Pre-Installed OpenOffice | alternative to MS Works & MS Office

Software, Desktops and Laptops submitted by dhart 02/17/07


Provide OpenOffice.org for free pre-installation alongside Microsoft Works and Microsoft Office. OpenOffice.org is more capable than Microsoft Works, and a serious competitor to Microsoft Office, at a fraction of the cost (it's free!)

OpenOffice.org can open, create, edit and save Microsoft Word, Excel and PowerPoint files.

Provide as OPTIONS for pre-installation many other high-quality free software programs such as:
- Firefox: web browser with popup and privacy controls; say goodbye to Internet Explorer infections!
- Thunderbird: email program with free anti-spam and privacy controls
- Pidgin: instant messaging all-in-one program for popup-free MSN, Yahoo, AOL and others
&nsbp;[ed: GAIM was renamed Pidgin in April 2007 to settle the issue with AOL's trademark on AIM]
- PDFCreator: creates Adobe PDF files from any program
- Scribus, Inkscape & GIMP: desktop publishing, freehand drawing & powerful image editing
- Audacity & VLC: multi-track audio editing & universal all-in-one media/video/movie/DVD player
- Stellarium & Celestia: planetarium viewer & outer-space mapping, like Google Earth, but for our Solar System

Pre-installed quality free and open source software drastically lowers the cost of new PCs, and helps prevent software piracy. Cast your vote for Linux and other free software. Cast your vote for the Universal Education PC [ed: article removed/merged by dell_admin] utilizing free software.

CHOICE is what consumers want on their new PCs, not annoying surprise circus-ware (the typical smattering of confusing 3rd party popup-infested software found on most new Dell PCs). Quality free and open source software is well behaved, and may be legally pre-installed on PCs, and legally shared with friends and family, sharing is encouraged! Cast your vote for consumer CHOICE and public transparency at Dell.
574 Comments »

1389

Smartphone

Accessories (Keyboards, etc.) submitted by gautam 02/16/07

The Dell Axim PDA is not super-popular, but I think if it moved into the SmartPhone realm (especially in order to compete with upcoming iPhone) then it could pick up some market-share and be a great device for US cell phone providers. 92 Comments »

433

Too many confusing brands

Dell Web Site, XPS products submitted by silversow 02/17/07

Look at the XPS line on the US site. There are 4 systems to choose from, all basically the same, but with different base configurations and prices. Why not just offer 1 XPS system that the user can then upgrade to meet his/her needs. At the very least reduce the number of base configurations to 2 or 3 like on the Canadian site. 3 Comments »

4070

Internet Laptop Design Contest

Advertising and Marketing, Laptops submitted by mucho 02/16/07

In order to get direct input from Dell customers, and tie more closely with consumer trends, why not sponsor a contest over the internet to design a line of laptops for home/consumer use? This would tie into Dell's philosophy of direct relationships. So the new laptop would not only be built specifically for you, but also DESIGNED directly by Dell customers. Of course, designs would have to be reviewed by Dell engineers to be sure that they are technically feasible and can be built within cost constraints, etc... Seems like this could be a very cool way to design a new generation of home/consumer laptops thru collaboration directly with Dell customers. 9 Comments »

11950

Could Dell Own Green?

Environment submitted by adrian 02/01/07 **REVIEWED**

Environmental concern and sustainability are today real issues with consumers and voters in many of Dell's markets. It looks as if a genuine commitment to reducing carbon and cleaning up their footprint will become a more important factor for companies wanting to strengthen consumer loyalty in the coming years.

Dell has already made its environmental commitment clear.My suggestion is that this could become a hallmark of the company - why not make the products, literally, green? If Apple can own 'pretty' and IBM/Lenovo can own 'serious', why can't Dell own 'green'?
Dell continues to do a lot to support our environment like our Plant a Tree for Me program and other activities documented on our Environment blog on Direct2Dell. Click here for more details.




77 Comments »

22

Offer educational software with PCs

Education, Desktops and Laptops submitted by kalopch 02/18/07

Offer educational software, such as the free software presented at:
http://www.jimmyr.com/blog/Speed_Math_Trainer_Program_126_2006.php< has a game style interaction that makes users feel they are playing a game, while at the same time improving their skills. Comment »



Rss track my votes