DELL XPS 15 R3 - the new standard for laptops

June 27, 2012

4 Votes

Status: Archived

Promote

Current XPS 15 (L521X)

I am very pleased with the DELL XPS 15 L521X and how it looks. It manages to offer a Mac alternative with emphasis on quality, luxury and elegant design without being a blatant copy. It also has a very nice price point and offers 512GB SSD without adding an outrageous extra sum.

However, there's always room for improvement, so let's get to it!


SCREEN
Taking intel's resolution roadmap into consideration, we'll get even more focus on high resolution displays on all units, and the laptop is no exception. Since XPS stands for "Xtreme Performance System" and is synonymous with premium quality, it demands the best alternative that will be common within 2013/2014 if the roadmap holds some truth and the current high resolution trend continues. The resolution for premium units is 3840x2160 pixels. Corning Gorilla Glass 2.0 with anti-glare would be optimal as it's stronger, lighter and provides brighter images.



COOLING
The L521X has good cooling, but I think the main problem is that all the air is led in and pushed out on the bottom of the unit, making it a bit uncomfortable to use on your lap. With some tweaks, the cooling could be vastly improved. What I suggest is going back to the drawing board and revise the design of the hinges. The laptops with the best cooling all push the air out on the back of the unit through two big grills. Design the hinges so that two big grills or a big one can be added on the back of the unit. Add almost invisible holes on the side of the unit (maybe as part of the design?) to maximize airflow while you at the same time maintain the current design of the bottom. The new hinge design should be as anonymous and seamless as possible for a quality feel and look.


CPU
With improved cooling, you can add at least one high performance quad core alternative. The current i7 alternative is no slouch, but some users may want more.


GPU
As with the CPU, a higher performance GPU can be added with better cooling. A display with an extreme resolution of 3840x2160 pixels demands a powerful processor for use with demanding programs and games. Don't let the unit suffer just because it's not marketed as a gaming laptop. I find that most gamers would choose a more elegant laptop if they have the choice. The future is hard to predict, but have a nVIDIA GTX 660M (or the respective future alternative for middle segment GPUs) as standard and nVIDIA GTX 680M (or the respective future alternative for high-end GPUs) as a choice. 


PORTS
The current ports are quite satisfying, especially the USB 3.0 only with one of them being the always charging kind. The only port I miss is Thunderbolt. We're talking about the future here, and even now, many laptop brands have introduced units with Thunderbolt. It looks like it will become the future, and if not, you have only "wasted" one port. The resolution of this unit will also demand a port other than HDMI because of incompatibility, as a result, the Display Port will be more appealing. Ditch the HDMI and add the Thunderbolt port in its place instead. Offer a Display Port to HDMI converter in the package to please customers.


OPTICAL DRIVE
Add a Blu-ray XL burner (or at least a BDXL reader with normal BD burner). I've read countless posts about producers and users missing this. Blu-ray should be standard, as it will become the standard with the higher resolution movies that are just around the corner. 4K and 8K movies will be too big for the laptop's disk(s). An uncompressed 4K trailer of The Amazing Spider-man takes 500GB of your precious space. 500GB! The new format will most likely, as the current, be compressed in some way to fit on Blu-ray disks. The Blu-ray with the biggest storage space has been shown by Pioneer and TDK with an amazing 1TB. This shows that Blu-ray will most likely live on for some time.

4 Votes | 27 Comments | Report Abuse

Comments Page (1 of 3)

1 2 3 Next

Please login to IdeaStorm to post a comment.

    Idea Extensions :
  • Aug 29, 2012

    Report Abuse

    SCREEN 2.0
    - add 100% sRGB color space
    - even light distribution
    - proper cailbration 
  • Aug 27, 2012

    Report Abuse

    There's something I have thought of, but never realized until today:
    where's the love for the XPS logo on the new XPS series? If you swithc the DELL logo on the lid with a XPS logo, it will look much nicer (IMHO).

    User-added image

  • Jul 30, 2012

    Report Abuse

    SDXC SLOT
    This is the new high-end SD card and by including a slot that supports it, the laptop can suddenly have up to 128GB (at this time) of extra space. The theoretical maximum is 2TB.


    FANS WITH ACTIVE NOISE CANCELLING 
    To reduce the sound the fans generate, DELL could go for fans with active noise cancelling which works like active noise cancelling in headsets: a mic pics up the sound and a part then produces a signal which "cancels" the noise. Noctua has some interesting fans for desktop PCs, but it should be possible to apply the same method for laptops.

    If this presents too much of a challenge, the design of the fans could be altered so they produce less noise.


    SPEAKERS 2.0
    If is turns out to be too complicated and/or expensive to move the current speakers, DELL could utilize "audio exciters" instead. This does not remove the issue when the speakers are set on a soft surface, but improves the sound when placed on a solid one.
  • Jul 26, 2012

    Report Abuse

    COOLING continued
    Use a combination of copper and graphene for cooling - it's 25% more effective than copper and cheaper!
  • Jul 25, 2012

    Report Abuse

    IEEE 802.11ac 
    Better and faster wireless tecnology is important, and implementing it will make the laptop(s) even more appealing.
  • Jul 16, 2012

    Report Abuse

    LAPTOP POWER BRICK
    The power brick you get with the new XPS 15 is small, but it can be made even smaller and neater. When you have done that, you can use the same design across all DELL laptops. Who doesn't love less mass to carry? :)

    Razer made a really neat power brick for their Razer Blade:
    User-added image
    Try to make something like this, but with the DELL logo.
  • Jul 12, 2012

    Report Abuse

    PLACEMENT OF SPEAKERS
    The current speakers on the XPS 15 model are placed so that they face the surface the laptop is stationed on. This is not optimal for clear and good sound. When on a table or a solid surface, the sound is okay, but if you place the unit on metal or have it on a softer surface, the sound suffers. The sound experience should not be affected by the placement of the unit. The speakers need to be re-stationed or placed in a way that hinders this.

    Every review I have read mentions the sound being a huge step down from the JBL branded DELL XPS 15-L502X (2011 model). This is really bad for DELL's PR.

    "The sound from the XPS 14's bottom-mounted speakers did not offer sound that was nearly as rich as from last year's Dell XPS 15".
    - Laptopmag.com


    "It doesn't sound like DELL invested extra cash on sound quality with the XPS 15. The sound is as flat as we're used to on laptops and the performance is okay for "light entertainment". The bass is totally absent and we would advice audiophiles to invest in external speakers or headphones. Even the cheapest external speakers are better than the speakers in this unit".
    - Hardware.no



    The ASUS Zenbook UX31A suffers from the very same issue due to a similar placement of speakers:

    "As far as audio quality is concerned, I've got some unfortunate news to report: though we praised the speakers on the original UX31, Asus decided to change them anyhow. Rather than solely firing audio out of the LCD hinge like competing designs, Asus has cut two speaker vents along the edges of the chassis that face down, and whether that's a cause or a coincidence, the result is much weaker, flatter, and tinnier sound at any volume. Bang & Olufsen, whose branding is featured on the chassis, would not be proud. You'll want headphones".
    - The Verge


    Please do not make the same mistake twice ;)
  • Jun 30, 2012

    Report Abuse

    User-added image

    A rough sketch of the improved cooling - the light grey areas are new

    - The curved sides now have passive cooling
    - The back of the unit has one big grill and the hinges are now lifted a bit higher to allow maximum air flow when the air  is pushed out on the back. The black areas are where the old cooling vents were. They kan be kept for better cooling, or ditched for a more sturdy design - whichever proves more valuable.

    Subwoofer
    The unit now has a JBL subwoofer stationed on the middle of the bottom for the best and most precise sound experience along with improved sound.
  • Jun 30, 2012

    Report Abuse

    SPEAKERS 
    The current speakers on the XPS 15 are too anonymous and have thin sound. DELL should try to improve the sound and make it thicker with decent bass and a wider sound spectre. If possible, a small subwoofer could be added to the bottom of the unit. It would then be the only unit with such an elegant and thin design with this feature. A new "DELL only"?
  • Jun 28, 2012

    Report Abuse

    KEYBOARD
    Make the keys matte to improve the quality and look even more.
    Comments :
     
  • Oct 27, 2012     Comment Link

    Report Abuse

    For me the hub for Lightning Bolt is a benefit, as I could plug printer, mouse, screen, etc to it.
    So when I come home, I only need to plug in one cable to use it all (like a docking station).

    And on the go USB 3.0 is enough for me, as my mouse and external HDD don't need the speed of Thunderbolt.

    But neither Thunderbolt, nor Lightning Bolt are a replacement for additional USB slots.

    The only thing I can think of, that is limited of USB 3.0/DP and would benefit of Thunderbolt is:
    A fast SSD, but I don't think that many people have external SSDs, as they are expensive and have low capacity compared to HDDs.

    So for me Lightning Bolt is the clear winner.
  •  
  • Oct 20, 2012     Comment Link

    Report Abuse

    The thing with Lightning Bolt is that it takes away from the portability. Who wants to carry extra hubs? I sure don't.
    The technology is also far from mature enough. If it turns out to be a good solution later on, it might be a good thing to implement in DELL products, but as of yet, it isn't good enough. That being said, Thunderbolt is not a superior standard at all, it just provides the best speeds.

    With time, I think Lightning Bolt has a chance of becoming the best standard as it is based on the most common port: the USB. A lower production- and implementation cost is also something one shouldn't underestimate.

    Therefore, it would be wise to keep an eye on the Lightning Bolt technology and its development.

  •  
  • Oct 1, 2012     Comment Link

    Report Abuse

    I agree with BeLan, Lightning Bolt would be far more useful, and won't add to the cost significantly like Thunderbolt.
  •  
  • Sep 20, 2012     Comment Link

    Report Abuse

    Down sides of Thunderbolt:
    1. It's no open standard, so Intel is and will be the only one producing the controllers and they can dictate the price, as there is no competition
    2. You need active cables, which are expensive
    3. Thunderbolt doesn't fully support DisplayPort 1.2, as it can't handle more than 10 GBit/s in one direction, but 17,28 GBit/s would be required
    4. The planned optical version could handle DP 1.2, but looses the possibility to power the external device
    5. There aren't that much Thunderbolt devices out yet and i doubt that this will change
    6. Do you know how much controllers you have chained, when you connect an external HDD to a notebook over Thunderbolt?
    - 2 Thunderbolt controllers, one in the notebook and one in the external HDD
    - 2 transceivers in the cable, one on each end
    - 1 SATA controller to connect the HDD to the thunderbolt controller
    Makes 4 chips more, than when you connect a external HDD over USB.
    I didn' check the numbers, but I don't think that this is very power efficient.
    Also thats one of the reasons, why Thunderbolt stuff is so expensive.

    I'd rather have a Lightning Bolt port.
    Less chips, likely less power hungry, MUCH cheaper, more compatible devices available and more likely to become an open standard.
    And it doesn't require Dell to hack around the problem of Thunderbolt, that PCIe was not designed for hot-plugging.
    The only 2 drawbacks are:
    - You need a hub, but for notebooks a hub can also be a positive thing (it's like a docking station)
    - The USB 3.0 part doesn't reach it's full speed in the first version. But if if you really need the full speed, then you can also use the USB 3.0 port on the notebook.
  •  
  • Aug 29, 2012     Comment Link

    Report Abuse

    I  have the DELL XPS 15 L521X which I use for work (software development). So to me it's all about being able to look at the screen comfortably for long periods and having decent colour reproduction. Obviously the keyboard is also important.

    I think this screen is pretty bad, especially given the cost of the laptop. It's just not pleasant to look at and the colour is all wrong and impossible to get right. Mine has a horrible blue tint that you just can't seem to get a good balance.

    So for my use case I'd like to see:

    1.  A much better quality screen.
    2. A matte screen option.
    3. A better keyboard (particularly having separate home/end pg up/pg down keys).

    Extra screen resolution is fine, but I'd rather Dell got the basics right first.

    I appreciate that others may be using it more for watching movies and maybe the screen suits that better!?


    The acutal form factor and speed of the laptop are perfect for me.
  •  
  • Jul 31, 2012     Comment Link

    Report Abuse

    Hi danielps! Thank you for posting and showing your interest! :)

    SCREEN
    If DELL does not offer more than 2560x1440 on forthcoming laptops with 15''+, they will be passed by competing brands, who offer higher resolution within the same price range with the same amount of power (compare the ASUS UX31A to the DELL XPS 13). It is not likely that there will come laptops with more than 3840x2160 because the human eye won't be able to see the pixels.  By going for "retina display" early and making it a standard, DELL can reduce the cost. By introducing such a high pixel density, it will affect battery life and require more GPU power, but not as much as you suggest. The MacBook Pro with Retina can handle intensive programs used for video editing without hickups at the native resolution: 2880x1800. Games do not fare well on it, but that has more to do with optimization than anything else. Windows has the upper hand with Direct X and all the features embedded within it. With one solution comes new problems, and DELL would need to address them. A more powerful battery and smart use of nVIDIA Optimus when not doing demanding tasks could bypass this. It's all about refining and tuning to get the last bit of juice out of the machinery.

    CPU
    Yes, the new model should have a similar i7 as an offering, but for the users who demand more for serious work, an even more powerful CPU could be listed as a choice. DELL is known for offering tailored machines, and this would be a missed opportunity.

    GPU
    The DELL XPS 15 is designed as a Xtreme Performance System. Extreme performance should be synonumous with the option for a high-end GPU. I have already listed suggestions for improvements that could make the machines cool enough to handle it. I agree wholeheartedly with you when it comes to price/ performance. It's the most important part for customers and will ultimately affect their decision.

    CONNECTIVITY
    HDMI is not needed because you get a display port to HDMI dongle with the laptop. However, you are right when it comes to Thunderbolt. I forgot about that... So: Thunderbolt port instead of Display port, with a dongle for HDMI connection. Do note that HDMI is not compatible with resolutions above 1080p.

    OPTICAL DRIVE
    Yes they do, and the format is far from dead. BDXL will most likely live a long life, considering the cheap cost of the discs compared to SSDs and HDDS that you can only have one of in the DELL XPS 15 (in addition to a mSATA drive). When 4K and 8K arrives this year, will you want to carry a 2TB HDD with you for a maximum of 5 - 10 lossless movies? Many care when it comes to picture quality and resolution. If you want thinner designs, you already have the DELL XPS 13 and 14.

    SPEAKERS
    If DELL provides speakers that are above the competition and stay with that design, they will have another positive feature. It doesn't hurt to have extra features if the cost doesn't become too high. By presenting a new standard, the money used on developing it won't be thrown out the window. XPS 1502x had high-end speakers that received praised from every technology corner.

    POWERBRICK
    :)

    WIRELESS
    I agree, but by being early, DELL will receive "free" PR and have another feature to list as unique. It will also be cheaper in the long run to ditch the old standard and just have the new one instead. Use it across all DELL units.

  •  
  • Jul 31, 2012     Comment Link

    Report Abuse

    Screen: 
    Higher screen resolutions also require more powerful graphics card, adding to cost and decreasing battery life. A 2560x1440 screen would be a suitable step up without major compromises elsewhere.

    CPU:
    The current i7 provides a good balance between cost, performance and power requirements. The next model should stick with a similar class of CPU.

    GPU:
    A more powerful GPU will be needed to drive the higher resolution, but this isn't designed as a gaming laptop. Give the highest end GPU as an option for the gamers, but price and power is more important here than raw performance. 

    Connectivity:
    3x USB 3.0 ports is adequate. HDMI is needed for the same reason older laptops had VGA, because all other equipment had it. However, how many TVs, projectors and home-theater systems have display port? If you want Thunderbolt (which has the functionality of Display Port and PCIe), then remove the Display Port connector.

    Optical Drive:
    People still use this? Remove the optical drive completely, offer a USB 3.0/Thunderbold external drive if necessary. Removing the internal drive will make the laptop cheaper, lighter, and could lead to better cooling or thinner designs. Laptop users on the move use portable hard drives, wifi and SD cards - not Blu-ray.

    Speakers:
    Speaker quality is not a top priority. Have something that is suitable, but not extraordinary. While I appreciate the excellent speakers and sub in my Studio XPS 16, I just as often connect to external speakers and headphones when watching movies. The money could be put to better use elsewhere.

    Powerbrick:
    Of course, smaller is better, and selecting components with low power requirements will make it possible to reduce the size.

    Wireless:
    The new 802.11ac standard would be nice to have, but not a must have, as the majority of routers will not support it for some time.

  •  
  • Jul 28, 2012     Comment Link

    Report Abuse

    Hi Cy_J!
    Yes, and not too hard to implement either :)
  •  
  • Jul 27, 2012     Comment Link

    Report Abuse

    I saw the article on copper and graphine, interesting stuff.
  •  
  • Jul 2, 2012     Comment Link

    Report Abuse

    OK, I think I have it this time.  :)

1 2 3 Next