STEVE HARVEY ON HAVING BIG IDEAS
The Dell Community has contributed: 9375 ideas | promoted 641925 times | 71543 comments

How IdeaStorm Works:

Post Promote Discuss See
-370

DELL OS

-370 points posted to by bubuasb 11/12/07 **NOT LIKELY**

Dell should create its own operating sistem like Apple

aikiwolfie
11/12/07
Windows, UNIX, Solaris, Apple OS, Amiga OS, Linux (multiplied by a bazillion if you count each distribution separately), and Haiku are just a few of the OSs competing for user support. What we don't need right now is another OS.
matt_d
11/12/07
The operating system is, in the end, merely infrastructure for applications - applications the user wants to use to get their job done, play their games, or learn. There are plenty of operating systems out there competing for mindshare by the application authors. There's no reason for Dell to create a Dell-unique operating system. Dell does already sell Microsoft Windows versions, several Linux distributions, and yes, even Solaris to some customers.
bubuasb
11/12/07
And suporting one of these and customizing it too Dell philosophie and realising it under the brand name is bad?
aikiwolfie
11/12/07
Hi matt, welcome back. How'd you manage to make such an awesome revelation sound so dull. Dell sells SOLARIS! Well actually I knew that already. I just wanted your attention. Focus on my watch as it swings back and forth and repeat after me

Dell will adopt Ubuntu as it's primary OS.
Dell will adopt Ubuntu as it's primary OS.
Dell will adopt Ubuntu as it's primary OS.
Dell will adopt Ubuntu as it's primary OS.
Dell will adopt Ubuntu as it's primary OS.
Dell will adopt Ubuntu as it's primary OS.
Dell will adopt Ubuntu as it's primary OS.
Dell will adopt Ubuntu as it's primary OS.
Dell will adopt Ubuntu as it's primary OS.
Dell will adopt Ubuntu as it's primary OS.

... and your awake!

So what's the deal with Ubuntu anyway? Are we going to see it on a half decent system? I have it running from a USB drive with an XPS 700 dude! Aparently the folks at Gentoo Linux know how to configure dmraid to work with NVIDIAs mince RAID setup. Maybe you should give them a call. Make a date. Discuss it over coffee. Bang some heads together. Get us a decent Ubuntu system.

Please? ... Don't make me use the sad puppy eyes!
aikiwolfie
11/12/07
It's not bad bubuasb. It's just not required.
dwood
11/12/07
Just have dell buy out novell and re-write openSUSE eh? Arent they getting down in the dumps with that M$ deal?
davmcn
11/12/07
don't think it would go that well...but nice try anyways..
dwood
11/12/07
Cosh seems to always be on the exact opposite of public opinion.
davmcn
11/12/07
Not really, he just has his own personal opinion. Everyone Does.
aikiwolfie
11/13/07
Maybe he just likes to be different?
aikiwolfie
11/13/07

http://www.levenez.com/unix/



It seems Dell do have their own OS after all. Dell UNIX. Probably not suitable for Joe Public though.
matt_d
11/14/07
We haven't sold Dell Unix for quite some time - before my time, and I've been here over 13 years. :-)
aikiwolfie
11/14/07
Man your old!!! LOL you still have it though. Dell UNIX that is. So anyway bang heads together and get Ubuntu on a decent system. Like I've been saying all over IdeaStorm, it works on an XPS 700! Just take your own advice from linux.dell.com and disable the raid array or alternatively figure out how to use dmraid. And then tell me first so i can be first to have it working :oD
sazar
11/16/07
Apple didn't create it's own OS. It added it's own custom features to an existing OS.

Dell has a different priority set and continues to make money and provide solutions with that priority set. Creating a different OS would be a waste of resources since Ubuntu and Vista (and XP) are such good operating systems anyways.
dwood
11/16/07
Where have all of the Dell -logo employees gone?
mugunth
11/17/07
Dell cannot write even a single driver...
matt_d
11/17/07
@mugunth: Dell employees certainly do write, and assist with maintenance of, Linux device drivers. Just a few examples in the Linux source tree we've touched:

drivers/firmware/{edd, efivars, dell_rbu, dcdbas}*
drivers/char/ipmi/*
drivers/scsi/*
drivers/pci/*
drivers/net/*
petzymathuram
11/17/07
Hi Matt....Dell can have either Microsoft/ Linux/ whtever OS created exclusively for it's official / office dealings within the organization

The OS adopted within an organiztion should have the Dell Logo embeded within the OS used by any member of the Dell Organiztion. Say for eg a Power Point template...The power point template used by any member within the Dell organization should all be uniformly designed with the Dell Logo ...and any borders to match the purpose. Similarly an Excel sheet / MS word...the history should denote as Author:name of the department , date of creation, and the name Dell ( Organization's name)

what is your opinion Matt?....;). I posted this long time before in the Dell website...;)
davmcn
11/17/07
Sounds Like Matt this morning got mad at Mugunth.
petzymathuram
11/17/07
@ Mugunth...but it's really very bad on your part to mock at Dell...I request you to stop it plzz
davmcn
11/17/07
i request also...not to be offensive to anyone , but since i've ntoiced you come on here all you've done it mocked dell and been mean to many users.
dwood
11/17/07
petzy, you promoted. :P
davmcn
11/17/07
lol :)
aikiwolfie
11/17/07
It's great that you guys contribute to Linux matt. So what's the hold up? Why can't we get it on a decent system?
davmcn
11/17/07
that would be nice...
dwood
11/17/07
yes, it would.
aikiwolfie
11/17/07
It would be nice if someone from Dell could answer that simple question instead of constantly ignoring it.
davmcn
11/17/07
Yea.
dwood
11/17/07
I dont think its ignoring, its the inability to answer the question. Unless Matt is one of the people setting up the Linux systems, then theres little/no way Matt, in such a large company, knows the answer
aikiwolfie
11/17/07
I doubt matt does know the answer. But someone at Dell must know the answer ... right?
dwood
11/17/07
Yeah, but I doubt that person is going to read this idea and see your question.
aikiwolfie
11/17/07
I know. So sad Dell don't really intend to deliver.
petzymathuram
11/17/07
@ dwood, I promoted this idea keeping in mind the idea I have discussed with Matt.....plz look above for the comments I posted to Matt...;)). under the banner "Simplifying IT for Organizations"...;)
matt_d
11/17/07
aikiwolfie: what's your definition of a "decent system" please? Every Server, every Precision workstation desktop model (don't tell me those aren't "decent", and now several Inspiron systems, with more in the pipeline I expect you'll be pleased with. But you're right - I won't pre-announce anything here.

petzymathuram: I don't understand your question, please elaborate. Dell does have a common PowerPoint template, but I don't think that's what you're looking for.

dwood: I'm closely related to the team that sets up the Ubuntu systems. I was the engineering team lead for 8 years before moving into a strategist position in the Office of the CTO. So while I'm no longer responsible for the day-to-day operations of the team, I do stay very familiar with the plans.

davmcn: I'm not mad, just clearing up incorrect perceptions. :-)
davmcn
11/17/07
@matt_d: just backing you up, are you guys going to Put Linux on Xps Series? or am i stupid and it's already done?
petzymathuram
11/18/07
@ Hi Matt- Thanx 4 Yr response....My question is for any OS..ie MS / Linux / etc etc used by Dell employees within Dell . The OS used by an employee within Dell needs to have a Dell Logo. The used OS application history details needs to have info like date created/ date modified/ Name of the organization: ie Dell.

When any OS application like a MS word or Excel used by any employee within the organization gets used up outside the organization, the history needs to show the display the Dell logo.

Is there a method that can be used to embed the Dell logo in every page of MS word/ Linux / excel sheet / linux?

My question is that ...if this is possible?
If this is possible will it help in minimizing Organizational data loss ?
Is there a method to track the misuse of Organizational specific OS when used outside the organization?
will this not be helpful for departments that deal with financial documentation / or any type of data transaction?

Does Dell have these features? Is this possible Matt?....tell me plzz...;)
aikiwolfie
11/18/07
This is the minimum configuration I think Dell should be advertising with it's PCs. All of these options are the Dell recommended options that are highlighted in green in the configuration screens. Advertise something like this and people will be more interested. Make Dells recommendations the default system and let people down grade if they want to.

Doing it this way makes the product look more attractive and ensures people who aren't comfortable configuring a system will get a decent system that will cope with their changing demands. People buy PCs thinking they'll use it just for e-mail and web browsing and then end up with a digital camera and gigs of photos and videos.

I do however think Ubuntu should be made available with all compatible systems. Including the XPS range. In the US the 420 I think is touted as something like a multimedia work station but in the UK it's pushed as a high end games rig. So Dell has already realized these machines are versatile and they appeal to more than just gamers.

Dell claims it's targeting PC enthusiasts with Ubuntu. PC enthusiast buy system like the XPS 420, 700, 720 and 720 H2C. They don't buy the Inspiron 530. That's because gamers and enthusiasts are largely one and the same crowed. But I suspect you already know that matt.

At the very least add a dual boot option to the OS selection.

Components

PROCESSOR...................................N-Series Intel® Core™ 2 Duo E6550 Processor (2.33GHz, 1333Mhz FSB, 2MB cache)
OPERATING SYSTEM............................Ubuntu Desktop Edition Version 7.10
MONITOR.....................................Dell™ 22" Black Wide Flat Panel (E228WFP) - UK/Irish
MEMORY......................................1024MB 667MHz Dual Channel DDR2 SDRAM [2x512]
HARD DRIVE..................................320GB (7200rpm) Serial ATA/100 Hard Drive with 16MB DataBurst™ cache
GRAPHICS CARD...............................128MB nVidia® GeForce® 8300GS Turbocache graphics card
OPTICAL DRIVE...............................16x DVD+/-RW & 16x DVD Drives
KEYBOARD....................................Dell™ Entry Quietkey USB Keyboard - UK/Irish (QWERTY)
MOUSE.......................................Dell 2 Button USB Scroll Optical Mouse - Black


Accessories

SOUND SOFTWARE..............................Integrated 7.1 Channel High Definition Audio
SPEAKERS....................................Dell™ A525 Speakers with Subwoofer
FLOPPY/MEDIA DRIVES.........................No Floppy Drive
MODEMS......................................No Modem


Services & Software

HARDWARE SUPPORT............................1 Year Base Warranty - Collect & Return
LINUX SUPPORT...............................No Ubuntu Support
ACCIDENTAL DAMAGE SUPPORT...................No Accidental Damage Support


Also included with your system

Gedis Bundle Reference......................Inspiron 530 - Ubuntu
Dell System Media Kit.......................N-Series Resource DVD - contains Diagnostics and Drivers
Shipping Documents..........................English Documentation with UK/Irish Power Cord
Order Information...........................Inspiron Desktop Order Uk
Standard Warranty...........................1 Year Base Warranty - Collect & Return
Online Promotion Option for GEDIS Configs...Dell Internet Order.






















dwood
11/18/07
Aiki.... Gutsy Gibbon just came out. how could you overlook that?
Also, linux Support should be a mandatory 90 days (or loonger) no matter what
Speakers with Subwoofer? are you crazy? Id be happy with just a pair of decent speakers
Also, 320 GB is a lotto expect for a "decent" system. I have 230GB and I am still having trouble filling it up. 7200 rpm's is decent.
22" can be a bit overwhelming for people a 19"would be better.
Other than that, your specs of a "decent" system are pretty good.
aikiwolfie
11/18/07
You're right. Add Gusty to that spec. I was concentrating on the hardware. I was trying to be fair to Dell and give them a break by making the spec something they could offer without having to really redesign anything.

I would have settled for a 20" display. But it wasn't on the list. Once you start messing with videos and photos and MP3s 230GB doesn't last long. I actually meant to pick the 500GB drive. Don't know what happened there but 320GB is good enough.

1024MB of RAM should be standard these days. I don't believe in configuring systems to the bare minimum you can get away with. To make a good impression on the customer it isn't enough for the system to just cope. It needs to perform. It should excel at the tasks the user challenges it with.
petzymathuram
11/18/07
Gutsy Gibbon = Ubuntu
Penguin = Linux
windows = Micrsoft

what else?...;)
dwood
11/18/07
Ubuntu is Linux >.<
petzymathuram
11/19/07
Hi dwood, there was a different OS installed in our systems 2 day...ie e-press...e-press excel etc...
I need to learn 2 mrw....I was not interested 2 learn today, I just switched over to MS appstream appln

what is this e-press? is it Linux too? dwood I need your kind reply..;)
dwood
11/19/07
..... first off. what? please re-explain without abbreviating so I can understand what your problem is so I can help fix it.... lol,
petzymathuram
11/19/07
@ dwood... today when I logged into my system...I found E-press Operating System installed....

I tried to researching the E- Press Excel spreadsheet...got bugged but switched to MS appstream

what is E- Press?...is it something like Linux / Ubuntu dwood?
petzymathuram
11/19/07
what happened there's no reply from U ...??????
aikiwolfie
11/19/07
E-Press
dwood
11/19/07
i am sorry I have never heard of e-press.
aikiwolfie
11/19/07
I just did a Google search. That's all it gave me really. Never actually heard of them my self but i have heard of Panda Antivirus. Did you install anything else petzy?
dwood
11/19/07
I would remove E-Press. It sounds like it is some ad-infested spyware.
ah1f
11/30/07
Just what the worl needs another OS for us to lear and complain about.
dwood
11/30/07
Rofl they are all based on the exact same kernel.
aikiwolfie
11/30/07
The kernels might be the same but there are a lot of different packages that are considered a part of the OS. Some distros use package 1to do task A while others use alternative package 2. Aditionally not all kernals are equal. Graphics drivers can be compiled directly into the kernel. But some distros refuse to use closed source drivers. So one kernel might have the nvidia driver while another will only have the vanilla VGA driver. That obviously affects the various features the OS can support. Which in turn determines the support services the vendor has to provide.
matt_d
Jan 19
Changed status to **NOT LIKELY**.
jackie_c
Jan 22
matt_d has posted several comments to this thread. If you have questions as to why this is "Not Likely", please see his comments.
jdelidc
Jan 22
they don't need to. they are the only ones i know of that sell ubuntu. they just gotta market it and people will think that it's dell's
Please log in to post a comment