Explain the status tags somewhere

How IdeaStorm Works:

IdeaStorm Comments | IdeaStorm Ideas

320

Explain the status tags somewhere

320 points posted to IdeaStorm by mistern 07/20/07 **IMPLEMENTED**

It seems like you just added a whole lot of status tags like "** NOT NOW **" or "** NOT LIKELY **". Could you please add an official list what these wonderfully laconic codes mean? Most codes are of course self-explaining but there's still some uncertainty left.

Thank you.

Click here for status tag definitions.

kontithegreek 07/20/07	agree 100% with this idea
dell_admin1 07/20/07	Here are the tags we're using. There is a large team of us tagging today. IMPLEMENTED PARTIALLY IMPLEMENTED COMING SOON UNDER REVIEW NOT LIKELY NOT NOW ALREADY OFFERED IN PROGRESS
jorge 07/20/07	NOT NOW = Yea, its nice but we're not doing that but want to mark it so you don't blow a gasket. NOT LIKLEY = You have got to be kidding! It might be viable in some weird circumstance or un-foreseeable future so we're not going to piss you off and we'll mark it this way so you don't blow a gasket. PARTIALLY IMPLEMENTED = We offer it somewhere in our product line which may or may not be related to this idea but we don't want to figure it out we just heard that its somewhere at Dell at the water cooler, so. REJECTED = They don't want you to do something drastic so they won't ever use this one. NOT IN YOUR LIFETIME = reg isn't getting MacOS X on a Dell.
jorge 07/20/07	I think you need a separate Idea for each as to what they mean, otherwise its too much for them to remember to explain the tag.
mistern 07/20/07	"NOT NOW = Yea, its nice but we're not doing that but want to mark it so you don't blow a gasket." I wouldn't be sure about that, for example. Wouldn't it rather be "Nice try, idiot"?
jorge 07/20/07	I was being nice.
mistern 07/20/07	And that's why we need a list with explanations.
jorge 07/20/07	I totally agree, but One thinks the names is enough for some unknown/uncommented reason, much like the status tags, there is no explanation and there won't be till we bombard them with maybe 20 duplicate ideas asking for it.
mistern 07/20/07	number of duplicates is the real indicator of value to dell?
dell_admin1 07/20/07	no mistern.
dell_admin1 07/20/07	DEFINITIONS: IMPLEMENTED -- Dell has listened and we have put this idea into action. The idea is implemented. PARTIALLY IMPLEMENTED -- Part of this idea was implemented, but not all of it. We might tell you on these ones that certain products or certain regions implemented it, but not all. COMING SOON -- It's not ready for sale yet, or otherwise "visible", but we've committed to delivering it in the future. UNDER REVIEW -- Our team is reviewing this idea and evaluating it against criteria that include, but are not limited to: market impact, regional demand, feasibility, appropriate timing, vendor/supplier availability, etc. NOT LIKELY -- For reasons stated in the comment box, this is not likely to be implemented. NOT NOW -- Right now we do not plan to offer this, but we have not ruled it out for the future. It may be a good idea down the line. ALREADY OFFERED -- We already offer this. IN PROGRESS -- Working on this as we speak. (similar to coming soon)
cosh 07/20/07	What happened to ACKNOWLEDGED, FIXED, and UNDER CONSIDERATION? There are still ideas tagged with those.
dell_admin1 07/20/07	They will be changing. those 3 are no longer valid tags. Reason is: a) people thought "acknowledged" meant we were saying "no", but that was not the case, so we created some new tags that were more descriptive, b) "fixed" is not the right way to describe an idea, c) "under consideration" is basically now "under review" - the term "review" describes our process better than "consideration", since we do some evaluation work.
cosh 07/20/07	That's good to know. Thanks! I keep a list of the ideas by status you see: http://d354310.u39.digiweb.ie/ideastorm/tags.htm
dell_admin1 07/20/07	of course! Glad you keep that list :)
zed260 07/23/07	Merged Idea originally posted 07/22/07 meaning of terms on ideastorm what does all these mean example PARTIALLY IMPLEMENTED COMING SOON UNDER REVIEW IMPLEMENTED it would be nice to know what each of these mean and how likely each means that the idea will be implemented
davmcn 07/23/07	Merged Comment originally posted 07/22/07 COMING SOON = means they are working on it and it is oviously coming soon UNDER REVIEW = means that dell is reviewing the idea and may take it into consideration. IMPLEMENTED i think it means they are proceeding with the idea. You Can ask The admins also they are on every once in a while...Not sure if all these are completely Correct if anyone else knows please help me correct.
dell_admin1 07/23/07	Merged Comment originally posted 07/23/07 DEFINITIONS: IMPLEMENTED -- Dell has listened and we have put this idea into action. The idea is implemented. PARTIALLY IMPLEMENTED -- Part of this idea was implemented, but not all of it. We might tell you on these ones that certain products or certain regions implemented it, but not all. COMING SOON -- It's not ready for sale yet, or otherwise "visible", but we've committed to delivering it in the future. UNDER REVIEW -- Our team is reviewing this idea and evaluating it against criteria that include, but are not limited to: market impact, regional demand, feasibility, appropriate timing, vendor/supplier availability, etc. NOT LIKELY -- For reasons stated in the comment box, this is not likely to be implemented. NOT NOW -- Right now we do not plan to offer this, but we have not ruled it out for the future. It may be a good idea down the line. ALREADY OFFERED -- We already offer this. IN PROGRESS -- Working on this as we speak. (similar to coming soon)
davmcn 07/23/07	Merged Comment originally posted 07/23/07 i was close...
winoffice Jan 26	jorge: "NOT NOW = Yea, its nice but we're not doing that but want to mark it so you don't blow a gasket. NOT LIKLEY = You have got to be kidding! It might be viable in some weird circumstance or un-foreseeable future so we're not going to piss you off and we'll mark it this way so you don't blow a gasket. PARTIALLY IMPLEMENTED = We offer it somewhere in our product line which may or may not be related to this idea but we don't want to figure it out we just heard that its somewhere at Dell at the water cooler, so. REJECTED = They don't want you to do something drastic so they won't ever use this one. NOT IN YOUR LIFETIME = reg isn't getting MacOS X on a Dell." That is hilarious indeed, LOL!!!!
jorge Jan 30	Still no status tag though, what up? * IMPLEMENTED *
jackie_c Jan 30	Changed status to IMPLEMENTED.
jorge Jan 31	Thanks I knew my definitions were dead on.

Please log in to post a comment

recently demoted by:

How IdeaStorm Works:

Categories

Status

IdeaStorm Team